Uncategorized patrickmead on 02 Feb 2010 02:07 pm
What Remains… hidden history
Explorers have found a great deal of skeletons, arrowheads, and the remains of several forts in the Falls area (southern Indiana and northern Kentucky — the Louisville area). A lot that was found, mapped, and recorded is now gone and that is a bit troubling. You see, a lot of early pioneer folk had no trouble confabulating stories and finds. It was almost a cottage industry. Trying to figure out which pioneer/explorer/farm owner was honest and which one wasn’t is a bit difficult when records are so sparse. Still, the sheer amount of finds from a wide variety of people of all walks of life is impressive.
Hundreds of skeletons of adult males over 6ft. 6in. have been found on both sides of the river. Their heads were oriented to the east but that isn’t the most interesting bit. Most of them were buried in the sitting position, facing east, with weapons in their laps. Almost all of them had skulls that had been hit by a blunt object on the left temple after the individual had died. Ritual breaking of the skull after death is only found in one other culture of which I am aware — British culture (meaning Welsh) from 900-1350AD. Local Indians describe the white settlers (sometimes called white indians) as very tall. Nearly a dozen skeletons were measured out at over seven feet tall.
A large pile of human bones has been found near the head of the Falls on Corn Island. This is probably all that remains of a massive battle the local Indians say occurred between them and the white Indians. This area has produced nearly ten thousand arrowheads, axes, and other battle implements over the last two hundred years, a great many of which are in museums and the rest in private hands.
In 1912, long past the heyday of faking artifacts, Craig Crecelius found a stone near Brandenburg, Kentucky which is still on exhibit at the Meade County Library nearby. It is sometimes loaned out so call before you go to visit. The Brandenburg Stone is an exciting find because it isn’t a pictograph — it is alphabetic. That means it could not possibly have been made by Indians for none of them had an alphabet until it was created for them by white missionaries and the great Indian Sequoya (1767-1843. His story is fascinating, by the way. Look him up). The writing could not be deciphered until, in the late 1960s, photos of the inscription was sent to a group of ancient historians including Brian Blackett and Alan Wilson. These men had already made a name for themselves in their study of an ancient Welsh alphabet called Coelbren. It was used by the Welsh (aka Britons, British) from the late 400’s until the 1800’s, though it remained in Welsh schoolbooks as an alphabetic option until 1910. The inscription read “To promote unity, to be wise, we divide the land for our children.” (this is an idiomatic translation. The original, if you go word for word, is confusing unless you understand the expressions and forms used by ancient Welsh. It reads something like “toward strength, divide the land we are spread over, purely between offspring in wisdom.”)
Several forts were found in this area with some impressive stone walls, but the walls were taken down, the stones shipped downstream and incorporated in the foundation of the railroad in 1895. We cannot say who built the forts. Some Indian tribes did use stones to lay out their defensive enclosures but most people I’ve talked to think the way the walls were originally laid out indicates European influence at least. I really don’t have an opinion on that. One fort, though, stood out. Rose Island, upstream from the battle site where the pile of skeletons lay, had a well described fort. It’s stones, too, were used by the railroad in the 1890’s but not before Herman Rave and others drew and wrote, in detail, about the layout of the fort. Rave said it most resembled the fortress of Pen Man Mawr which sits on similar topography in Wales. Rubble built stone walls rose 12 feet high enclosing an area of ten acres. A ditch was placed in front and behind the walls. Mounds were built outside of the enclosure which leads me to think that Indians had joined this band (regardless of some fringe writers, I think it is certain that Indian tribes built all of the mounds. There is no serious reason to think otherwise. They may have had help here or there, but it was plainly a part of the culture of several tribes). Those mounds are empty of artifacts and are considered places of worship or lookout mounds. The Rose Island fort is also known as the Great Stone Fort.
Unsurprising factoid: fifty nine years after the walls had been taken down and shipped away, Gerard Fowke, an archaeologist with the Smithsonian Institute, declared that the fort was not man made but a natural formation. For what it’s worth, Rave and others had also said that SOME of the walls were of natural origin. They believed the Welsh incorporated those natural outcroppings into their fort. That is not unusual for Celtic people. The great castle of Edinburgh, Scotland rests on top of a volcanic rock that was incorporated into its design. Photos below.


Stone towers, walls, and forts have been found all over this area. Most were mapped, drawn, and described before being taken down to be used for building materials in houses, streets, and bridges. Not much remains. It appears that there was a burst of activity and a flowering of the Welsh traditions before the Battle of the Falls. Afterward, the forts and villages were deserted. What happened to the Welsh is a story which needs to wait a few more days…
on 03 Feb 2010 at 9:01 am # Danny Gill
Is there a book you can recommend on the Welsh in the new world?
I’ve mentioned a few before. The best starting place is “The Welsh Indians” by Traxel. Available at amazon.com. His bibliography is rather impressive. I have followed him closely in this series but he adds a ton of evidences and detail that I have skipped over for various reasons. Ralph Walker wrote an extensive magazine article also called “The Welsh Indians” that someone has on Amazon in the used department. Another out of print, but still available book is by James Axtell entitled “White Indians.” After that, you have to go to scholarly articles in magazines, journals, and un-distributed theses and dissertations. Look at those detailing contacts with Mandan Indians, the Lewis and Clark expeditions, and the history of southern Indiana, Northwest Kentucky, and Eastern Tennessee. Some of the museums in those areas also publish their own literature.
on 04 Feb 2010 at 8:46 am # Danny Gill
Thanks, Patrick. I must have missed the earlier references. This is getting more interesting (and hard to ignore history-wise) all the time.
on 04 Feb 2010 at 11:41 am # Greg England
Many years ago, when I was still in high school, my dad told us about a farmer near Birmingham, AL who had a tract of land on a river. Don’t remember which river, but the farmer had told my dad that every year when he plowed that land, he unearthed thousands of pieces of shaped flint. So out of curiosity, we went to see the man’s field and, sure enough, we found hundreds and hundreds of arrow heads, spear heads, and pieces of pottery. The land was also filled with holes, which led to huge caverns. We “explored” a bit in the caverns, but mainly collected sacks filled with shaped flint. After reading your recent blogs, I wonder just how this would fit into the history you are laying out???
You likely stumbled on a factory. The various tribes would often share a natural outcropping of flint and produce baskets full of implements such as those you describe. My family has a trunk with a basket full of arrowheads and axeheads made by Indian tribes, found in northern Kentucky and southeast Ohio. I’d love to know more about the location of the caverns. Road trip, anyone?
on 04 Feb 2010 at 3:04 pm # Danny Gill
That sounds like fun, but be careful of burial sites. My grandfather and uncle were very avid arrowhead hunters. My uncle excavated a burial site discovered when one of the freeways was being built in San Antonio, and we always used to find worked flint when we walked the creekbeds after a heavy rain. He also caught Valley Fever in a burial cave in California. It very nearly killed him.
on 04 Feb 2010 at 3:10 pm # Greg England
Now that you mention it, I recall either the farmer or my dad saying something about a factory. I’ll write my brother and see if he remembers the location.
on 05 Feb 2010 at 1:24 pm # Danny Gill
Is that first book this one: Footprints of the Welsh Indians: Settlers in North America before 1492 by Traxel?
Yes.
on 09 Feb 2010 at 12:41 am # Jo Huddleston
Patrick, what a nice surprise happening upon your blog! It’s been years since your and your wife were visiting in our home near Drumnadrochit, Scotland! Have wondered where you and your family were. This info you give is most interesting! I’m sending your link to my son, Jon. He loves history like I do! Cheerio!
Jo! great to hear from you. I was looking at photos from that visit last week. Contact Kami and I via Facebook or via our church website at http://www.rochestercoc.org.
on 12 Feb 2010 at 1:59 pm # Dee Andrews
Hey, Patrick -
I’m just now getting around to reading all of the way through this post on what remains hidden history (with the comments about flint factories & the like) and commenting because I had neurosurgery on my left arm the day you wrote this.
I was out of pocket for several days and then my sweet daughter Rebecca had horrendous problems in Texas and had to make an emergency trip down here to stay with us for a while.
I LOVE all of your neat stories!! Can’t wait for you to get back home from soggy Louisiana to share some more. Today is the 12th and we had gorgeous fat snow flakes all morning here in south Miss. It’s all gone, of course, but was beautiful to see just a “bit” of snow.
Now back to warmer weather!
Dee